Dear Ms. Forssman and Board,
On behalf of Vancouver Water Watch and our Gabriola members who attended the May 29 Gabriola Freshwater Footprint Workshop (Session 2) and who read the RDN’s Groundwater Connections, we are writing to request answers to several important questions about the groundwater that remain unanswered. We welcome and appreciate the information that has been shared so far. However, we are still struggling to fully understand some aspects of the water project, the supporting data, and the implications for land use planning on Gabriola and the proposed Water Budget Study whose design could possibly be used on other islands. We are requesting that you answer our questions.
1. Concerns Raised by GW Solutions Consultants During the session, GW Solutions consultants highlighted the following serious concerns:
• Fractured bedrock aquifers are low-yield and highly vulnerable to contamination, seawater intrusion, and climate change.
• Climate change impacts are increasing risks to water quantity and quality. • Well deepening is increasing, with significant associated risks.
• Saltwater intrusion is increasing.
• Monitoring is limited or absent in many areas, especially in high well-density zones.
• Water quality threats include aquifer overuse, drought, earlier seasonal drawdown, and septic impacts due to reduced dilution.
Do you agree with these concerns? Will they be reflected in the Gabriola Water Budget?
2. Resident Contributions to Data Gaps:
How can residents, especially long-time landholders, contribute information to help close the data gaps identified during the session? Just as Indigenous knowledge holders are now valued, so too should the lived experience of residents inform our collective understanding of historic changes and the current state of water sustainability. For example, a resident shared that the Lockinvar Village/Triangle area was once well-watered. Their parents had an artesian well that supplied several homes, but now there is little or no groundwater during the dry season. Is such historical knowledge being sought and included in your data gathering? If not, why?
3. Use of Outdated Well Drillers’ Reports:
Some residents have expressed concern that the well data from Elanco Enterprises (Dakin) and other drillers, currently used by the RDN and GW Solutions, is outdated and no longer reflective of Gabriola’s groundwater availability. Has this concern been investigated? If so, what was determined? If not, why not?
4. Monitoring in High-Demand Areas:
Is it true that there are no records of water level trends from high-demand, high-density areas? If so, how will this critical data gap be addressed?
5. Need for More Monitoring Wells:
It was suggested that Gabriola needs more current data from additional monitoring wells, particularly in areas with high well density. Ms. Barosso, Senior Hydrogeologist, GW Solutions appeared to agree. Do you also agree? If so, is this being recommended and implemented? If not, could you please explain why?
6. Declining Water Levels:
GW Solutions’ records show a “persistent decline” in groundwater levels on Gabriola over the years. This decline is made evident by the millions of litres of water trucked to the island by two major water haulers; by the increasing number of cisterns that are being installed; and, the reverse osmosis system set-up in a high-water demand tourist facility. However, the RDN’s Groundwater Connections report describes trends as only “variable.” Will the “persistent decline” be clearly presented in the reports you are releasing to the public? If not, why? Can you please define the word “variable”?
7. Contamination of the groundwater by septic systems, over-pumping of existing wells (licensed or unlicensed), newly drilled very deep wells draining water away from shallower wells and saltwater Intrusion, these are all issues that Gabriola groundwater users experience. Unfortunately, the BC Government Groundwater policies do not protect the well owners, as the burden of proof is very expensive and as a result deters enforcement. In order to protect the groundwater users. How will the RDN address these problems and protect this important resource?
8. Why is development permitted when water quality and quantity is not required to be proved?
We recognize that significant data has been collected, but we are concerned that key information is still missing. While we are not experts, we believe the concerns outlined above are reasonable and deserve attention. We are trying to become as informed as possible on this critical issue.
Thank you, in advance, for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
June Ross
Chair – Vancouver Island Water Watch Coalition
Editor – www.vancouverislandwaterwatchcoalition.ca




