11th June 2016
Almost two years after slides began carrying heavy metals into creeks, few answers.
By Ben Parfitt, 8 Jun 2016, TheTyee.ca
Toxic heavy metals including arsenic, barium, cadmium, lithium, and lead are flowing into the Peace River following a series of unusual landslides that may be linked to natural gas industry fracking operations.
The landslides began nearly two years ago and show no sign of stopping. So far, they have killed all fish along several kilometres of Brenot and Lynx creeks just downstream from the community of Hudson's Hope.
As plumes of muddy water laced with contaminants pulse into the Peace River, scientists and local residents are struggling to understand what caused the landslides and why they continue.
Hudson's Hope Mayor Gwen Johansson is also worried about a broader question. The toxic metals are entering the Peace River in a zone slated to be flooded by the Site C dam. That zone could experience nearly 4,000 landslides if the dam is built, according to an assessment prepared for BC Hydro.
The risk alarms Johansson as BC Hydro, under the direction of Premier Christy Clark, pushes to advance work at Site C past "the point of no return."
"If this much damage can result from tiny Brenot Creek, what happens to the reservoir if we get thousands more landslides?" the mayor asks.
No definitive cause of the Brenot Creek landslides has been determined. But one possibility is that they were triggered or exacerbated by natural gas industry fracking operations, in which immense amounts of water are pressure-pumped deep underground with enough force to cause earthquakes. Fracking is also known to cause unanticipated cracks or fractures in underground rock formations, allowing contaminated water, natural gas, oil and other constituents to move vast distances undetected.
A fracking boom, and leaking holding ponds
Fracking was under way in the area in the years immediately before the first slides were noted at Brenot Creek in August 2014.
Between July 2010 and March 2013, a dozen earthquakes ranging between 1.6 and 3.4 in magnitude occurred in the Farrell Creek fracking zone, about eight km from Brenot and Lynx creeks.
By March 2013, both B.C.'s Oil and Gas Commission (OGC) and BC Hydro were increasingly concerned about "events" at Farrell Creek, according to non-redacted parts of Freedom of Information requests to BC Hydro and commission documents.
"Right now our focus is on getting the improved seismographic network up and running," Dan Walker, then the commission's senior petroleum engineer wrote in an email to Andrew Watson, BC Hydro's engineering division manager on April 7, 2013. "We will continue to monitor and study all cases of induced seismicity [earthquakes] in NEBC [northeast British Columbia]." The email was written two days after the last of the 12 earthquakes occurred at Farrell Creek.
By the time of that earthquake, Talisman Energy, the biggest natural gas company then operating at Farrell Creek, knew wastewater was leaking from one of four massive "retention ponds" it had built to store millions of litres of contaminated water from its fracking operations.
A detailed investigation paid for by Talisman and conducted by Matrix Solutions, an environmental engineering firm, notes that Talisman's "leakage management system" detected that contaminated water was escaping from between two liners that were supposed to trap and prevent Pond A's toxic brew from polluting the ground and water around it.
Pond A had likely been leaking for five months. In June 2013, Talisman drained the pond and confirmed the leaks had occurred. The OGC, which regulates B.C.'s oil and gas industry, subsequently ordered Talisman to drain the remaining three ponds. At that point, it was discovered that Pond D was also leaking toxic wastewater.
The wastewater ponds and gas reserves in the region are now owned by Progress Energy, owned in turn by Petronas, the Malaysian state-owned petro-giant. The provincial government is eager to see Petronas build a liquefied natural gas terminal at Lelu Island near Prince Rupert.
The toxic substances found in water samples collected from groundwater sources underneath Talisman's faulty storage pits included arsenic, barium, cadmium, lithium, and lead, the same compounds found in the billions of fine sediment particles that continue to turn the waters of Brenot and Lynx creeks a muddy brown before they enter the Peace River.
The Matrix Solutions report, released in May 2015, noted the release of toxic metals was predictable. Digging the huge pits and exposing massive amounts of unearthed material to the air created the risk of "surface and groundwater acidification," Matrix said.
"The primary concern for receiving environments related to acidic groundwater is the potential for release of trace metals," the report warned.
'Cows are not supposed to chew the water'
It's not known if the fracking-induced earthquakes or the failures at Talisman's waste ponds played any role in events at Brenot and Lynx creeks. No studies have been done in the region to determine how and where water moves below ground.
In its report of more than 2,200 pages, Matrix noted a troubling lack of groundwater information. "Flow direction is not documented," the Matrix report said. However, the report noted that groundwater generally moves from "topographic highs toward topographic lows." In other words, it moves downhill.
Below the Farrell Creek fracking zone, the waters of Lynx and Brenot creeks continue to be so full of contaminants that a person's finger placed just a millimetre below the surface disappears from view. The pollution caused one local farmer to quip that his "cows are not supposed to chew the water."
Martin Geertsema, a geomorphologist with the provincial Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations in Prince George, says he has never seen anything quite like what has the landslides at the site.
"We've got a camera pointed at the landslide," he said in an interview. "I'd like to install a few more to try to figure out what the heck is going on. It's very unusual. There's nothing quite like this."
"At other slide sites the water flows finished in a few days," Geertsema said. "The difference here is it just keeps going. Water is coming out of the base and because the water is eroding soil from the base it leads to cliff collapse. And the cliff is composed primarily of sand and some clay. And when it collapses, the debris just flows."
Geertsema noted the region is known for naturally occurring landslides, many of which show signs of "considerable antiquity."
However, today's slides are occurring in a region with some of the most extensive and intensive industrial land-uses in B.C., including two major hydroelectric dams and reservoirs and water-intensive fracking operations that the OGC has concluded in various locales in northeast B.C.
When the slides at Brenot Creek first began, the District of Hudson's Hope advised residents not to drink the water and the provincial government issued a similar advisory a few days later.
The district later paid a hydrogeologist and water expert, Gilles Wendling, to collect and test water samples at the slide site to determine how toxic the water was.
Mayor Johansson remains disturbed by the event's duration, its origins and most of all its timing. When the first landslide was discovered, the region had endured weeks of extremely hot and dry weather. A water-triggered landslide in August was, Johansson felt, highly unusual.
In January 2015, Johansson wrote an article in a district newsletter on the landslides and water contamination.
Environment ministry response 'pretty inadequate'
"I have contacted MoE [B.C.'s Ministry of Environment] to ask what further steps they are planning and to find out when the advisory might be lifted," she wrote. "The MoE representative said they have no plans to do anything further, other than file a report. He said he expected that eventually the creek would cleanse itself."
"That seems pretty inadequate," she continued. "Test results show levels of exotic metals such as lithium, barium, cadmium and others to be significantly above guidelines. They are not normally found in shallow ground or surface water. They have not shown up at those levels in any previous testing in the area, and I am not aware of similar readings being found anywhere in the northeast of the province. Some of the metals are toxic. They pose a risk to human and animal health."
During a recent interview, Johansson said her views remain unchanged.
The OGC, which visited the site shortly after the slides began, concluded the contaminants were commonly found in the soils around the creek and that a natural spring was the source of the groundwater.
"The 2014 landslide appears to be entirely natural, and is one of a number of similar landslides that have occurred along Brenot and Lynx creeks over the last few hundred years, resulting from natural geomorphic processes," Allan Chapman, the commission's hydrologist reported in November 2014.
Chapman added that the landslide deposited "a moderate volume of fine-grained silt" into Brenot and Lynx creeks. "I would anticipate that these deposits along the stream channels will continue to release the elevated metals into the stream water, affecting the stream water quality, for an extended period of time," he wrote.
But Wendling, the consultant hired by the district, has questions.
The slide was not a singular event, he noted in an interview from his Nanaimo office. Slides continue to occur there regularly.
Wendling said the only way to learn whether the presence of toxic metals in the water is natural would be to dig deep into the ground in the area of the slides and see whether the metals are found there. If they are not, and are being carried into the creek by groundwater, then where is the groundwater flowing from? And why does it continue flowing with such intensity so long after the first slides?
Such tests might shed light on whether major changes to the landscape, such as the nearby giant Williston reservoir and/or natural gas drilling and fracking operations, played a role in altering the direction in which groundwater flowed, Wendling said.
Wendling, an independent professional hydrologist, works closely with First Nation governments in the northeast who are concerned about the gas industry's impacts on water resources. He said the high volume of groundwater entering Brenot and Lynx creeks, the contaminated soils being carried in that water and the timing slides are all of concern. Typically, he said, such events occur in the spring months following periods of intense rain and snowmelt. But this one appears to have occurred in the middle of a drought.
Shortly after the slides began, Wending walked the area and was struck by the dramatically different water levels upstream and downstream of the point Brenot Creek enters Lynx Creek. Upstream, Lynx Creek was virtually dry. Downstream, the creek had 50 times the normal water discharge.
"Why do two similar streams have such a difference in flows?" Wendling asked. It important to investigate all possible explanations for "the discharge of larger flows of shallow groundwater in proximity to Brenot Creek."
However, no one is expecting any such investigations any time soon. Neither BC Hydro, the Oil and Gas Commission, provincial ministries nor the natural gas industry have groundwater flow monitoring wells in place.
Geertsema laments the lack of information.
"I think it would be very useful to characterize groundwater flows," he said. "It would help me and it would help the mayor whose backyard is where the problem is."
It would also be extremely useful in light of another uncomfortable truth about earthquakes and their potential to alter groundwater flows and trigger landslides.
Continued...in Part 2